HS2 Action Alliance Comment on Committee of Public Accounts High Speed 2: A review of early programme preparation

All quotes attributable to Hilary Wharf, director, HS2 Action Alliance.

PAC report

“The PAC makes devastating criticism – that there is no convincing strategic case; and out of date information and wrong assumptions were used which do not reflect real life.  How much longer do they think the tax payer will listen to their protestations that this £50billion white elephant is vital to the future of the UK’s economy?”

Wider Economic Benefit

Having had the environmental, speed, and business case destroyed, it is not surprising that they have spent a huge amount of tax payers money on new work to come up with the numbers they need to prop up HS2. While the KPMG report has not been made public, we are sure that once you strip out the ‘ifs’ and ‘buts’ the huge wider economic benefits will be as robust as Government’s budgeting and business case.”


“It is depressing listening to Ministers pushing a case which they know to be untrue. The only long distance services for London that is quieter than at Euston are those of HS1’s at St Pancreas. HS2 will do little or nothing to relieve the serious overcrowding on commuter lines, which is where the problem is. The promised extra capacity for freight and local commuting into London can’t be realised. In the latest business case the spare capacity was used up restoring some long distance passenger connections previously lost.”


Notes to editors:

HS2AA is a national organisation making the powerful case against HS2. It is a not for profit organisation working with over 90 local groups who believe HS2 does not represent an effective answer to the UK’s transport, economic or environmental needs. HS2AA have focused on an evidenced-based approach to challenging the business case, the environmental case and compensation arrangements.


For more information please contact:

Richard Houghton

Tel: 07803 178 037

Email: richardwhoughton@gmail.com